[nukkad] Re : Rohits Maths

["Ravi Menon" <>]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Compassion is the basis of morality. -Arthur Schopenhauer, 
philosopher (1788-1860) 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------


I did send thi sinearlier but i did not see it in the last couple of 
digests, so I am resending it.

First of all Rohit let me remind you of the age old adage, people who live 
in glass houses better undress in the basement!

<<" dono ke bich barabar loodak gaya." (hanging between the two sides, 
belonging to neither wholly).>>
I, rather my parents came to Bombay many years before I was born, as yours 
probably or theirs came from Gujrat, neither of us live there but do so in 
the Middle East. So I guess jitne aaap loodke utne hee hum bhi” (I hang as 
much as you do)

Then we come to the truth of your comments, arguing using fake numbers does 
not tell a true tale.
<<In Dubai Hindus are 26% of the total population. Of all Indians Hindus 
account for over 60 %, Muslims about 30%, rest christians etc.>>

Nothing can be fuirther from the truth. Please if u cannaot tell the truth 
don’t make up numbers
Ethnic groups:
o	Emiri 19%,
o	other Arab and Iranian 23%,
o	South Asian 50%,
o	other expatriates (includes Westerners and East Asians) 8% (1982) note: 
less than 20% are UAE citizens (1982)
Religions:
o	Muslim 96% (Shi'a 16%),
o	Christian, Hindu, and other 4%
Languages: Arabic (official), Persian, English, Hindi, Urdu

The source is here..
http://www.datadubai.com/people.htm


<<Only foolish Hindus in Kerala are mesmerized by worthless communism, 
something that flopped in its own territory. Among Muslims not even 2% and 
among christians not even 5% have taken to whatever kind of communism.>>
>From Now I suggest if you quote numbers you provide proof as well.
When the communists under EMS Namboodripad took over the government amongst 
the things they first achieved was giving all – irrespective of religion- 
the dignity to live by passing the land reform act. One that no other state 
in the country has been able to do. They also initiated the educational 
systems that see Kerala leading the rest of the country and most of the 
third world in sociological development that the rest of the country and 
some parts of the world  can only look at in awe.
Anyway I am hardly a communist so I really don’t care nor keep track about 
what else they achieved.

That is interesting statistics you quote. Are u a card carrying member that 
is privy to the lists that u have such exact numbers? As far as I see you 
are trying to give a sense of accuracy to the crap you quote. As far as I 
know in my family’s ancestral village there is a fairly large mixture of all 
religions in the communist parties (there are more than one)

<<There is frequent trouble in Mallapuram, Kannanore, Kasarkode>>
I agree there is trouble but these are localised. I never claimed we are 
absolutely free from riots and the like. You will never see the riots on the 
scale of what was witnessed in Gurat recently in Kerala.

<<Several times I have noticed that you are misguiding Nukkad with 
incomplete, twisted information.>>  see above I do not lie and provide 
statistics to vindicate. However please be a little more specific as to how 
I Have misled people.

<<Your people do not have leadership qualities like Togadia and hence you 
can't produce them.>>  THANK GOD!!!

<<In the past when there was no talk of Hindutva, you could not give the 
nation the likes of Gandhiji, Patel and Morarji. >> Sorry but I do not 
understand what you are trying to state here.

<<Your veins run tap water and that precisely is the reason.>>  We fight the 
enemy and lead the nations armies. Show me one Gujrathi general that has 
been the Commander in Chief of the Armed forces and then talk of tap water. 
That’s where the blood is fighting on the border to keep the country safe. 
Not joining a mob to slaughter a minority.

<<Aren't you aware you are rated second class in your own home state ?>>  In 
all of India if you are not a politician or a member of the scheduled castes 
and tribes you are second class.

<<It can only happen in your state that with only 7 members of Muslim league 
in the assembly, they can wrest from you three berths in the cabinet of 
ministers.>> Politics has always been a filthy game I have no comment on 
this because I don’t follow it.

<< Again the chief reason is the quality of tap water.>> The fluoride 
content should be improved you suggest? ;)


==================================================================
<<In Dubai Hindus are 26 % and there has never been trouble by
them.>>
Since I just proved that this is a lie I do not have to respond
=================================================================
Muslims are taking to violence even at those places where they are only 2% 
(USA for eg.)

By that argument Pakistan and the Gulf should be seeing mortality rates 
higher lets me use a sttaistic like  you 45 % more than the current ratethan 
th
================================================================
<<Hope you will tend to learn from the clear message of great Adi 
Shakaracharya.>>

You forget  he had to save Hinduism in the rest of India he felt it was safe 
in Kerala then as it  is today.
===================================================================
Rohit Zaveri.


Ravi Menon





_________________________________________________________________
MSN 8 limited-time offer: Join now and get 3 months FREE*. 
http://join.msn.com/?page=dept/dialup&xAPID=42&PS=47575&PI=7324&DI=7474&SU= 
http://www.hotmail.msn.com/cgi-bin/getmsg&HL=1216hotmailtaglines_newmsn8ishere_3mf


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To join/leave, use the form at: http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/#options
This list is archived at: http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/archive.html