RE: [nukkad] Nationalism, patriotism, and religion

[D D Karelia <>]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Non-violence leads to the highest ethics, which is the goal of all
evolution. Until we stop harming all other living beings, we are still
savages. -Thomas Edison, inventor (1847-1931) 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

|| Vande Mataram ||

.....[Mr Pankaj Gupta wrote : When someone asks me if I feel sorry that
Hindus are massacring the Muslims in Gujarat, I say--I feel ashamed as a
Human that we have started to take such narrow views. However, I do feel
sorry as a Hindu that we never welcomed the Muslims and the others in this
wonderful culture. I read this interesting comment by Gulzar in his
interview where he mentions most of the language we speak is Urdu, but we
tend to identify it with only a particular community. The same way, most of
our culture, be it a Muslim, a Shaivik, or a Vishnav is strongly linked to
Hinduism--we just find it easy to identify it with a particular community.]]

Dear Pankajbhai,

I hope u will be feeling proud when anyone asks u why Hindoos were butchered
by muslims, why always muslims start riots, why only Hindoo temples, idols
are damaged.  U may be feeling ashamed, but we do not.  After one thousand
years of humiliation we have found the root.  Forget Gandhi and his theory
to lend another cheek, but now has time arrived to not to retaliate but
OFFENSIVE IF BEST DEFENSIVE.

People like u feel sorry for HIndoos massacring muslisms, but u never go
into the reasons for the act, in fear of losing your secular identity.  Mr
Gupta, because u have not never got any experience from minorities, u may be
safe, but we people have experienced trauma of such incidents.  Cuddling
minority is not secular identity, the people of gujarat has learned now, and
tomorrow the people of Hindustan will act accordingly hopefully.

And Beware, Jains, Shikhs, Buddhists are part and parcel of Hinduism, pl do
not try to divide them, and let me add, Christianity and Islam can never be
adopted as religion of our land, since their religious faith lies somewhere
out of Hindustan soil. 

If u say Christian and Muslims were not given an opportunity to join into
mainstream, rather I will put it they were not interested to either join
into the mainstream of the culture, because of their overseas faith.  Who
have abstained them to join mainstream, if HInduism is cultural identity of
the people, and people engrossed in such culture are called Hindoo, these
minorities will keep themselves away from mainstream culture to keep their
religious identity intact.

I am not surprised that u are openly taking sides of minority, because
before one thousand year, there was one Prithviraj Chauhan a Hindoo
Identity, cheated and killed with the help Jaichand.  Prithviraj Chauhan
died, but Jaichand still today is alive.

Mr Gupta, Pl do not shed crocodile tear, enough is enough now.

Jai Hind, Jai ind Ki Sena
-deepak d karelia
|| Bharat Mata Ki Jai ||


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To join/leave, use the form at: http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/#options
This list is archived at: http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/archive.html