Re: Soul, mind and brain

[Kishor Valia <>]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tip of the day:  Do not include the entire message in your reply. Include only
the relevant parts.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------



Dear MC Guptaji,

It appears you join the ideas which you wish to link. In Aurvedic 
treatment, Sukshma sharir and sthool sharir meant that mind affects the 
body and similar way body affects mind.  What Jane Goodall said is that 
(observed) chimpanzees have capacity of having feeling like human beings. 
You took it as chimpanzees have soul. It proves my point.

2nd point that "mind" exists after body (movement-brething) stops. As you 
say you have studied science. Therefore, I assume you must have read theory 
of species evolution by Charles Darwin. Think about how many planets and 
stars are there in so many Galaxies. I hope you believe in one God theory. 
Then how God can account of so many souls. Think, at least, from last 20 
thousand years how many humans born and died and think of number of human 
beings in present day on this planet known as earth.  It appear that 
re-birth happens among Lamas of Tibet. Even Dalai Lama has admitted that 
this belief (Pratha-cusotm) will not survive in present day world. Is there 
any single case where one remembers past life? Do not give hearsay stories. 
Give recorded example.

I agree with one point that every human beings have 
Charisma-unseen(unobservable) personality. When we come in contact with the 
other person (male or female) his/her personality affects us. That is why 
we say when we keep company of good people we think good. When we keep 
company of bad people, we think bad. I hope you will take clue from 
this.  Once body looses activity, body dies and with it everything comes to 
stop. Do not make life complicated and make people to worry about the 
things they should not worry. Have logical & rational mind. This does not 
stop any one to remain religious and God fearing person.

Have a happy dream.

Kishor Valia.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To Subscribe [Unsubscribe] send a blank message to 
        nukkad-list-request@mumbai-central.com 
with the word 'subscribe' ['unsubscribe'] (without quotes) in the Subject 
of your message.
The list is archived at  http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/archive.html