Re: [nukkad] Blood Donation Camp of Bet-Dwarka

["Indian Rediff" <>]

Guptaji,

I could not resist. Here is blooper that you have committed in this e-mail.
A) Let us assume that Wahabi Islam is radical.
B) You say (with some purported proof) that Deobandi sect is derived
from Wahabi sect.
C) Ergo Deobandi cannot be more radical than Wahabi.

Just because Deobandi sect is derived from Wahabi sect, does NOT mean
that Deobandi sect cannot be more radical! How can this be, you ask?

Simple.
G) Wahabism is a sect of Sunni Islam (choose your lable - not 100%
sure that this is indeed the case. If it is actually Shia, please use
the Shia label. I am contradicting the logic of the statement).
H) Sunni Islam (or Shia - whichsoever is the inspirer of Wahabi Islam)
is a tolerant sect of Islam
I) Ergo, Wahabi Islam cannot be radical.

Now THAT is a blooper :-)

Sai

On 3/6/06, Dr.M.C. Gupta  wrote:
> Stronger than the Wahabi brand of Islam is the one in your own
> backyard. The Deoband School of UP from whom the Taliban draw
> inspiration.
>
> >> The fountain-head of Deobandi school is Wahabi Islam.
>
> [Ref: The Deoband School of thought was the by-product of the Wahabi upsurge
> in India and they did not leave any stone unturned in propagating and
> promoting the Wahabi ideologies, which they assertively called the Hanafi
> Mazhab. The very base of this Mazhab was to misguide the Sunni Muslim masses
> by misinterpreting the verses of the Holy Quran and the traditions of the
> Holy Prophet
> www.raza.co.za/Publications/ Publications_Great%20Beyond.htm - 110k -]


----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Blessed is he who has found his work; let him ask no 
other blessedness. -Thomas Carlyle, essayist and historian (1795-1881)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To join/leave, use the form at: http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/#options
This list is archived at: http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/archive.html