Re: [nukkad] Re: [nukkad] Akshay Joshi's views about Godse, Muslims and India

["aryaone" <>]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tip of the day:  Get your Bollywood fix here:
          http://www.mumbai-central.com/mboards/#bollywood
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dixitji wrote:
> Hi Arya,
> In the past whenver you wrote meaningless things , we don't
> care but this time you r just cross your limit.
>
and what limit is that? and what if i write nonsense? would you
in your New India silence me because of that? limit me by
pogroms? holocaust me? yellow star me like the moslem
iranis did the zarthusties, my ancestors, in 1100 to 1800?

> I don't know why you are talking non-sense all time.
> Don't you have anything better to do.
>
and you would have me explain, justify, what i do?

if i talk nonsense, dont read it.
i wont force you to rad, you should not force me not to write.

> Here it's a question of Godse and Gandhi and
> you want to create a rift between Gujratis and Marathis.
>
if for a moment that is what i am doing [which i am not] why
not discuss argue interpolate interject criticize it?

why this summary "dont write! its nonsense!

> Arya, why u r doing this.
> I just want to say  just stick to your meaningless poems and if you can't
> contribute nicely in any issue then don't.

what is "nicely?' if i thought i fitted this bill it would be a sorry
day for me.

in any case, it was my nonsense, not "nicely" which caused this flurry
of talk we are having.

> Hindustan is one identity and don't try to create
> so many identities.
>
really? and there are no factional disputes? nothing really happened
in Gujerat? there are troops at bhuj and srinagar? there are no
separatist, terrorist, religionist identity already out there?

there is no such thing as khalistan with a multibillion $ budjet and
zero trust for hindu sabha?

nothing is brewing with dozens of terrorist sleeprs in the land, there
is no danger to nuke depots, there are no small bombs poised to unleash
a mutated smallpox virus which vaccination cannot protect against?

there is no disenfranchisement, a lethal national apathy, naked
radicalism, terror-subscribed political factions, many mainstream?

there is no back breaking poverty? nepotism? rigged elections?

there is no killing girl fetuses every 15 minuets? dowry deaths?
child porno market in goat, mumbai?

there is no rampant runaway unemployment, restricted college seats,
rank favoring of money people in courts?

a judiciary you could buy with a month's wages in dollars?
far flung villages run by overloads, pundit chamchas, bought
magistrates?

> Mera Bharat Mahaan.
>

what in the world is that? is not the land everyone's.

and when was land, stone and earth, mahan?

mahan manas, agar shital kaam
nahi to mano jagat shamsaan.

arya






------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To Subscribe [Unsubscribe] send a blank message to 
        nukkad-list-request@mumbai-central.com 
with the word 'subscribe' ['unsubscribe'] (without quotes) in the Subject 
of your message.
The list is archived at  http://www.mumbai-central.com/nukkad/archive.html